The 2009-S John Tyler Presidential Dollar is worth anywhere from $2 to $15 for most circulated examples, but proof versions struck at the San Francisco Mint can fetch $10 to $30 or more depending on condition and packaging. If you found one of these coins tucked away in an old collection or a coin envelope, you’re in the right place to find out exactly what it’s worth.
coin identification app tools have made it easier than ever for everyday collectors to identify and value coins like this one without needing to visit a dealer. Whether you’re brand new to coin collecting or just stumbled across something interesting, this guide will walk you through everything you need to know about the 2009-S J. Tyler Dollar coin value.
What Is the 2009-S John Tyler Presidential Dollar?
The 2009-S John Tyler Dollar is part of the Presidential Dollar series launched by the U.S. Mint in 2007. This program honored former U.S. presidents in the order they served, and John Tyler — the 10th President — was featured on one of four coins released in 2009. The “S” mint mark tells you this coin was struck at the San Francisco Mint, which is significant because San Francisco produced proof versions of these coins rather than coins meant for general circulation.
Proof coins are struck using specially polished dies and planchets, giving them a mirror-like finish and sharper detail than regular business strikes. The 2009-S Tyler dollar was sold directly to collectors through the U.S. Mint as part of proof sets, so you won’t typically find one in everyday pocket change. If you have one, it’s almost certainly a collector’s coin and should be handled carefully to preserve its value.
2009-S J. Tyler Dollar Value by Condition
Condition is everything when it comes to coin values. Even though the 2009-S Tyler dollar is a relatively modern coin, its value still varies quite a bit depending on how it’s been stored and whether it shows any signs of wear or damage.
Here’s a quick breakdown of approximate values:
| Grade / Condition | Estimated Value |
|---|---|
| Proof (PR65) – Original Mint Packaging | $10 – $20 |
| Proof (PR69 DCAM) – NGC or PCGS Graded | $20 – $35 |
| Proof (PR70 DCAM) – Perfect Grade | $40 – $80+ |
| Loose / Ungraded Proof | $2 – $8 |
As you can see, a coin still sealed in its original U.S. Mint packaging commands a noticeably higher price than one that’s been loose in a drawer for years. If yours came in a blue or red proof set box, hold onto that packaging — it matters.
How the S Mint Mark Affects the 2009 Tyler Dollar Value
The mint mark on a Presidential Dollar tells you a lot about what kind of coin you have. Philadelphia (P) and Denver (D) mint marks indicate coins made for circulation, while San Francisco (S) mint marks point to proof-quality collector coins. For the 2009 Presidential Dollar series, the San Francisco Mint produced deep cameo proof coins that are popular with type collectors.
You can check detailed 2009 Presidential Dollar value information by mint mark and grade to compare how the S-mint version stacks up against P and D mint examples. In most cases, the S proof coins are worth more than circulated business strikes simply because of their superior finish and the fact that they were made in lower quantities for collectors.
If you’re using CoinKnow to identify your coin, you can scan the mint mark and the app will instantly pull up current market data to give you a real-time value estimate.
Where to Sell Your 2009-S Tyler Dollar
If you’ve decided your 2009-S John Tyler Dollar is worth selling, you have a few solid options. Online marketplaces like eBay are the most popular choice because they connect you with buyers from across the country who are specifically looking for Presidential Dollar proof sets. Searching completed sales for “2009-S Tyler Dollar proof” will give you a realistic sense of what people are actually paying right now.
You can also visit a local coin dealer, though keep in mind dealers typically offer 50–70% of retail value since they need to make a profit on resale. Coin shows are another great option — you’ll find knowledgeable buyers who can quickly assess your coin and make a fair offer on the spot.
For current pricing data on related 2009 dollar coins, this 2009 Native American dollar price guide with MS grade values is a helpful reference point for understanding where the broader 2009 dollar coin market sits.
CoinKnow is also a great tool for checking real-time sale prices and comparing your coin to recent auction results before you decide where to sell.
Tips for Protecting Your Coin’s Value
A few simple steps can make a real difference in preserving — or even increasing — the value of your 2009-S Tyler Dollar. First, never clean a proof coin. Even a gentle rinse can cause micro-scratches that destroy that beautiful mirror finish and drop the coin’s grade significantly.
Store proof coins in their original U.S. Mint packaging whenever possible. If they’re already out of the packaging, use inert coin flips or airtight capsules to prevent moisture and environmental damage. Avoid touching the coin’s surfaces directly — handle it by the edges only. If you’re thinking about getting your coin professionally graded by PCGS or NGC, that’s worth considering for any example in near-perfect condition, since a high-grade certified coin can sell for two to three times what a raw, ungraded coin would bring.
Using CoinKnow can help you decide whether professional grading makes financial sense for your specific coin before spending money on the submission process.
FAQ
Q: Is the 2009-S John Tyler Dollar rare?
A: It’s not rare in the traditional sense, but it was only sold in proof sets directly through the U.S. Mint, so it was never in general circulation. Mintage numbers were in the millions, making it a common collector coin, though high-grade PR70 examples are harder to find.
Q: What does DCAM mean on a proof coin grade?
A: DCAM stands for Deep Cameo, which describes the strong contrast between the frosted design elements and the mirror-like background fields on a proof coin. PR69 DCAM and PR70 DCAM are the top grades for proof Presidential Dollars and carry the highest values.
Q: How do I tell if my coin is an S mint proof or a regular dollar?
A: Look on the obverse (front) of the coin near the edge for a small letter. An “S” means it’s a San Francisco proof. You can also use a coin identification app to scan the coin and confirm its mint mark and variety instantly.
